Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Top Ten Tuesday - Best Female Historical Fiction Detectives

Happy Tuesday!

I've noticed myself reading quite a bit of historical detective fiction, and noticed that they all had one thing in common: a kick butt female detective. And so, I have compiled a list of these top notch ladies:

10. Liza Hastings, Prisoners in the Palace by Michaela MacColl

After her parents were killed when their carriage crashed, Liza was forced to find a job, something that would have been beneath her had her parents lived. She bears her lot in life with such grace, barely allowing herself time to grieve over her unfair situation. This girl was able to balance the bratty and selfish future Queen Victoria, the plot of usurping fiends, and a nosy, but handsome journalist, all without losing her cool.

9. Marjorie McClelland, the Marjorie McClelland series by Amy Patricia Meade

Marjorie is a charming young mystery writer who lives in a quiet town during The Depression. Nothing happens in this town until a charming millionaire moves into an old mansion nearby and a murder is discovered. Add in the handsome detective assigned to the case and you find yourself involved in a delicious love triangle. All the while, Marjorie is taking direction from no one, trying to solve the murder on her own, and proving that women can be strong, smart, and feminine at the same time.

8. Mary Quinn, The Agency series by Y. S. Lee

1860s London was not an attractive place. Sights and sounds and overpowering smells (oh god, the smells!) invade the senses, and day to day life was a game of kill or be killed. After her parents' deaths, Mary  is forced to live the life of a street rat. To avoid unwanted attention from unscrupulous men, Mary disguises herself as a boy. Unfortunately, she is caught stealing, a crime punishable by death. Her last minute rescue by a school for girls keeps her off the streets and trains her for a more adventurous life. The school is just a cover for a network of spies, The Agency. Mary is the kind of spy that will stop at nothing to finish her mission, even if it involves "pretending" to conspire with the attractive young engineer, James Easton.

7. Penelope Lumley, The Incorrigible Children of Ashton Place series by Maryrose Wood

Penelope is an orphan who, after graduating from The Swanburne Academy for Poor Bright Females, is assigned to be a governess at Ashton Place. Her mistress, not much older than Penelope, is a spoiled rich woman who wants nothing to do with the three peculiar children her husband found in the woods. It's Penelope's quick thinking and Swanburne mottoes that help her tame these wild children. But there's someone out there who does not have the well-being of the children in mind and it's up to her to protect them. Penelope is the kind of babysitter that every child wished they had and has the mind of a top notch detective.

6. Maisie Dobbs, Masie Dobbs series by Jacqueline Winspear

Maisie's father sent her to live with Lady Rowan Compton when she was thirteen, and the good Lady discovered just how bright Maisie was. Taking great care to educate her, she ensured that Maisie would have a life like no other woman of her station. After serving as a nurse in The Great War, Maisie comes back to England to train as a private detective. Her first case involves a suspicious farm for men injured in the war. It's Maisie's recollections of her life during the war and how she's still coping with them that make Maisie such a fascinating character.

5. Jade del Cameron, Jade del Cameron series by Suzanne Arruda

Jade is a fascinating woman who found her roots as a tomboy on her parents' ranch in New Mexico. During The Great War, Jade enlisted as an ambulance driver, experiencing horrible sights and sounds, including witnessing her fiance be shot by enemy fire in his airplane and plummet to the earth. To say that she is scarred is an understatement, but that doesn't stop her from taking an assignment as a photojournalist in Kenya and proving to the men there that she is by no means a fragile lady. When a mystery crops up involving her dead fiance, she will go to any means necessary to solve the case and put his memory to rest. Along the way she meets some dashing men who are frustrated yet intrigued by her spark for life and pave the way for some fascinating romance.

4. Flavia de Luce, Flavia de Luce series by C. Alan Bradley

The youngest of three sisters, this 1950s eleven-year-old chemistry genius (her specialty is poison) is a force to be reckoned with. When a murder happens in her own yard, her curiosity compels her to solve the case, even if it means finding herself in some pretty precarious situations. This bright girl will either end up as the director of Scotland Yard or winner of the Nobel Prize for chemistry. Or both.


3. Sally Lockhart, Sally Lockhart Trilogy by Philip Pullman

Before he died, Sally's father made sure to school her in the important matters: how to shoot a gun, run a business, and military tactics. Left poor after her father's death, she's forced to live with an old relative, one who is not so keen on Sally's "wild" ways, and wants her to conform to the current Victorian standards of womanhood. But Sally knows that there's more to her father's estate than his colleagues are letting on, and when mention of a deadly gem surface, her life is in serious danger. Thankfully she has Frederick, Jim, and Adelaide to help her navigate her through this seedy underworld of London.

2. Nefret Forth AND
1. Amelia Peabody, Amelia Peabody series by Elizabeth Peters

My mom handed this book to me when I was in high school. I thought it would be super lame, but at the time I was fascinated by Ancient Egypt and mysteries so I gave it a shot. If you want to meet the two most kick butt women ever to grace the mystery genre, then you MUST pick up this series. Amelia's the only daughter in a house full of boys, and it is left to her to tend to her father in his dying days. After his death, he leaves ALL of his money to her, and instead of demurely taking her place in London society of the 1880s, she enlists a traveling companion and sets off to explore Egypt. Her and her companion, Evelyn, find themselves at an archaeological dig headed by the Emerson brothers. There, Amelia finds a dead body and some unlikely allies. Along the way, the Peabody gang amasses more members, including Nefret (I won't give too much away about her, but this girl accomplishes almost as much as Amelia). Amelia offers us her practical thinking (what other woman in that time period would wear trousers simply because they allowed her to move more freely?) and sharp wit, and combines the history of the times with that of Ancient Egypt and more dead bodies to produce the most lovable heroine of all time.

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Matched by Ally Condie

Matched by Ally Condie
Dutton Books, November 2010
366 pages
Book Source: Public Library

Cassia has always trusted the Society to make the right choices for her: what to read, what to watch, what to believe. So when Xander's face appears on-screen at her Matching ceremony, Cassia knows with complete certainty that he is her ideal mate . . . until she sees Ky Markham's face flash for an instant before the screen fades to black. The Society tells her it's a glitch, a rare malfunction, and that she should focus on the happy life she's destined to lead with Xander. But Cassia can't stop thinking about Ky, and as they slowly fall in love, Cassia begins to doubt the Society's infallibility and is faced with an impossible choice: between Xander and Ky, between the only life she's known and a path that no one else has dared to follow.
-- Summary from Goodreads.com

Judging by the cover...: The picture on the cover is, to put it mildly, odd. I guess it's symbolic of Cassia trapped by the Society's rules and regulations, but I think they could have found some other way to demonstrate that. I find myself wavering on the specific color green they have chosen. On one hand, it's nice to have a visual for the color of the dress she wore to her matching ceremony. On the other, it gets a little nauseating after a while. This would be one for an ereader if you have a choice.

Favorite Elements:
  • The Game Center - Never mind that your recreation time is limited, or that you only get three options of where to spend it, because one of those options is The Game Center. When my two hours of free time come around, that's where you'll find me.
  • Back Story - Every dystopian novel has some kind of intriguing unraveling of events that led to this new type of world. The story behind Matched is not completely different than that of other dystopian novels, but nevertheless bone chilling and nightmare inducing. I wish more world leaders would read books like this; they might realize that things need to be changed now to avoid being like The Society in the future.
  • Poetry - What can be more romantic than having illicit poetry, written illegally on a paper napkin, secretly slipped to you by the boy you're forbidden to love? I can't think of anything.
Overall: C+
I had a very hard time getting into the book, and the chapter early on with the grandfather didn't help AT ALL. I stuck with it, though, and I'm glad, but I wasn't blown away at the end. This does not mean that I won't still read the sequels, but I was expecting this acclaimed book (it won a spot on the 2011 Texas Lone Star list, among others) to pack more in its 366 pages than it did. What it did pack in between its covers felt forced, like it didn't know where it was going. It seemed to reach in too many directions at once, and the end was rushed and didn't quite fit the rest of the book. Ky's character, in particular, didn't seem completely fleshed out, and I would have liked to see more into his mind. 

I think we can all sympathize with Cassia's constant bombardment from her parents, her grandfather, and The Society about how she should be vs. the girl she really is inside. Books of this nature always make us ponder what we would do in a similar situation, and thoughts of this kept me wide awake at night wondering.

Recommendation: If you need to fill a void in your longing for another dystopian novel, or if you can't possibly live without another love triangle, by all means read this book. It's a quick read, fast-paced, and frantic, and is a good space filler after reading other, more acclaimed, books in the same genre.

Similar Books: The Hunger Games series by Suzanne Collins, The Giver by Lois Lowry, The Uglies series by Scott Westerfeld.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Vanished by Sheela Chari

Vanished by Sheela Chari
Disney-Hyperion, 2011
336 pages
Book Source: This copy was an e-book ARC from NetGalley.com. The release date is set for August 9, 2011.

Eleven-year-old Neela dreams of being a famous musician, performing for admiring crowds on her traditional Indian stringed instrument. Her particular instrument used to be her grandmother’s—made of warm, rich wood, and intricately carved with a mysterious-looking dragon. When this special family heirloom vanishes from a local church, Neela is devastated. As she searches for it, strange clues surface: a teakettle ornamented with a familiar-looking dragon, a threatening note, a connection to a famous dead musician, and even a legendary curse. The clues point all the way to India, where it seems that Neela's intrument has a long history of vanishing and reappearing. If she is able to track it down, will she be able to stop it from disappearing again?
-- Summary from GoodReads.com

Judging by the cover...: There is something about this type of cover that calls me. It looks just like the covers from The Incorrigible Children of Ashton Place series by Mary Wood. The drawings say to me, "Read me, I'll be extremely fascinating." And if you think that's crazy, then you should know that the voice is usually right.

Favorite Elements:

  • Musicians - Neela is dedicated to learning how to play the veena, even when she doesn't feel confident in her ability. Musicians have a type of passion that radiates from them, calling attention to their ability and love.
  • Crazy Instruments - Take it from the girl who played the bassoon, crazy instruments are AWESOME. People might not have heard of the veena, but they will know what it is after you show just how cool it is.
  • Blending In/Standing Out - Neela's parents bring something different to the table in this book. We are constantly shown families who have moved from one culture to another and refuse to give up the old ways, making their children choose between offending their parents and fitting in, or being an outcast for life. The Krishnans have chosen to encourage their children to embrace both Indian and American cultures, taking the good parts of both, and in doing so, have well-adjusted kids. Neela feels sorry for her friend, Pavi, who is sheltered by her Indian parents, making her wear a bindi and staying away from boys completely.
Overall: A-
I don't remember what I expected this book to be before I read it, but it turned out to be completely different in reality. And I was quite pleasantly surprised. Neela is such a strong character, and I'd give anything to be her friend (well, back when I was in 6th grade, anyway). I was a tad bit nervous about the Indian culture aspect of the plot, not knowing a lot about it. I shouldn't have had any worries, though, because Chari explains everything we need to know without making us feel ignorant. The mystery of what happened to Neela's veena is non-stop action, and kept this reader on the edge of her seat.

Recommendation: This middle grade read, rich in culture and with a dash of romance, is perfect for girls ages 10 to 12, but boys will be drawn in by the mystery.

Similar Books: The Ring of Rocamador and The Vanishing Violin by Michael Beil (both in the Red Blazer Girls series).


Guest Reviewer: Gray Wolf Throne by Cinda Williams Chima

This week's guest post is brought to you by Mr. Frank, the resident high fantasy expert.

The Gray Wolf Throne (Seven Realms series #3) by Cinda Williams Chima Disney/Hyperion, 2011
528 pages
Book Source: This copy was an e-book ARC downloaded from NetGalley.com. The release date is set for September 20, 2011.

Han Alister thought he had already lost everyone he loved. But when he finds his friend Rebecca Morley near death in the Spirit Mountains, Han knows that nothing matters more than saving her. The costs of his efforts are steep, but nothing can prepare him for what he soon discovers: the beautiful, mysterious girl he knew as Rebecca is none other than Raisa ana’Marianna, heir to the Queendom of the Fells. Han is hurt and betrayed. He knows he has no future with a blueblood. And, as far as he’s concerned, the princess’s family killed his own mother and sister. But if Han is to fulfill his end of an old bargain, he must do everything in his power to see Raisa crowned queen.

Meanwhile, some people will stop at nothing to prevent Raisa from ascending. With each attempt on her life, she wonders how long it will be before her enemies succeed. Her heart tells her that the thief-turned-wizard Han Alister can be trusted. She wants to believe it—he’s saved her life more than once. But with danger coming at her from every direction, Raisa can only rely on her wits and her iron-hard will to survive—and even that might not be enough.

The Gray Wolf Throne is an epic tale of fierce loyalty, unbearable sacrifice, and the heartless hand of fate.
-- Summary from Goodreads.com

What I like about this series is that though the intended audience is young adults, Chima doesn't let that influence her writing. She doesn't dumb down the story for her younger audience, like many children and young adult fantasy writers do. They tend to use this as an excuse to not write a complicated story, making the story too general, never giving the plot enough depth to fulfill all of the reader's questions. I was, however, expecting this book to be the last in the series and felt at the end that she could have included more in the climax to wrap up the story. This downside is hardly worth mentioning when considering the intricate world Chima has created. An enjoyable read and I am really looking forward to the next one.

Similar Book: The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss

Sunday, April 3, 2011

The Mockingbirds by Daisy Whitney

The Mockingbirds by Daisy Whitney
Little, Brown and Company, 2010
332 pages
Book Source: Public Library

Alex, a gifted music student, has had an incredibly horrible experience just a few days after returning to the campus of her progressive private school. While attending a concert off campus, her and some friends play a drinking game, and the next thing she knows, she's naked in the bed of a strange boy. What happened that night?

The school administration believes that its students can do no wrong, and Alex immediately knows that they will not help her. She turns to a group of students known as The Mockingbirds, a secret society dedicated to keeping the peace among the students. This story is Alex's account of what happened before, during, and after her fight for justice.

Judging by the cover...: A quick glance at the cover would have you believe that this is a quiet, calm book. Until you read the tag line at the top, that is. "Hush little students, don't say a word..." The understated cover serves its purpose perfectly, lulling the reader into a false sense of security and then slamming them over the head with a disturbing crime.

Favorite elements:
  • Secret Society - Ever since reading The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau Banks by E. Lockhart, these clandestine groups of students have fascinated me. The Mockingbirds are there to police the student body, which makes them even cooler. Does anyone want to start one with me?
  • Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird - My family has a strong attachment to this book (my mom even named her dog Scout), and I was thrilled to see that it influenced The Mockingbirds. From Boo Radley to Atticus Finch, The Mockingbirds mete out justice in a way that would make Lee proud.
  • A Nod to the Queen City - As a Buffalo girl, I would have to be comatose to not be proud that my beloved Buffalo Sabres made an appearance. The friendliest city in the country needs more shout outs like that. (And now I'm craving chicken wings, darn it!)
Overall (out of 5): 3.75
Alex deserves a medal for being such a strong girl in the face of an evil frat boy wannabe and his friends. All I wanted to do while reading the book was to give her a hug, but I'm sure that she would think I was pitying her. One day she'll come to terms with what happened, but in the meantime, she has some kickbutt friends and an awesome sister to help her get there. 

For the story to progress the way it does, however, the adults in the story were painted as ignorant buffoons. For any girl reading the story who had experienced the same events as Alex, it might convince her to not seek help from an adult. At least Whitney gave us one redeeming teacher, Ms. Damata, but her appearance and help comes too late for it to do any good. It's almost as if Whitney added her at the last minute.

Recommendation: This book is not for pleasure reading. But if you're willing to help Alex walk down her road, I encourage you to pick it up. I would not recommend this to someone who had just recently been through the same experience, but it would be a good story to spread date rape awareness and spark a debate about what constitutes consent.

Similar Books: Just Listen by Sarah Dessen and Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson.